Over all everything was cool until I started to notice several people using the wrong photos of him in their posts. They were using a picture of Lim Hyunshik from BTOB that they got from Pinterest or Facebook groups (BTS Facebook groups are notorious for spreading misinformation so if you are on there please be aware of this). It was annoying because how do you call yourself an ARMY, which to me is beyond just being a regular fan, and post how much you love a member of your ult group and post the wrong picture of them as a child in your birthday tribute?
I politely informed a few of the posters that they had the wrong picture up and informed them of who they had posted incorrectly. The first person I informed deleted her post hours later and let me know she deleted it. That's how these things should go. I made a post on my Threads account asking ARMY not to use that picture and I posted the photo of Hyunshik with a side by side of him wearing the same thing as an adult as he recreated the picture of himself as a child. I thought that was common sense enough to show that it was not Namjoon. The second person I commented to didn't get it at first and proceeded to go back and forth with me over it. That's when I realized what a real problem this is.
Because they got the picture from Pinterest, they thought that anything pulled up on Pinterest is somehow automatically legit. Pinterest is used by many as a search engine, is it not? Well the thing is, all of these search engines are run by AI and AI is trained using the information fed into it by humans. This happens whether you intentionally add to it or not. The internet uses all kinds of content to feed AI. This user on Threads showed me the screenshot where she had put "Namjoon baby pictures" (or something to that effect) into the search on Pinterest and the first pic that shows up is this one of Hyunsik. She was adamant that it was Namjoon because that is what she was shown. I asked her to search "Hyunsik of BTOB" and see if it comes up and sure enough the picture not only showed up but it showed up where other people had made posts saying "this is not Namjoon this is Hyunsik." That's when she got it and acknowledged that the picture was mislabeled when she found it.
When you tag a picture, caption it, or otherwise label it as someone or something that it is not, the searches are going to show it as that (if enough people do it). There are so many people who have wrongly listed this picture as Namjoon that when I reverse search it using Google Lens I have to scroll past at least 10 to 15 links from all across the internet until I get to one that mentions Hyunsik. That's pretty bad because all over YouTube, Facebook, Pinterest, Tumblr, X/ Twitter and everywhere else this pic is being put out there as Namjoon and even the corrections are being ignored. I saw one where the person being corrected by a member of BTOB fandom says to them that Namjoon confirmed that it was him (giant eye roll). Why are people like this? You know if someone took the pic of Namjoon in the bumper car with his dad wearing coveralls or the one where he was rollerskating in the Mickey Mouse tee (his actual baby/child photos) and insisted over and over that it was say, a member of EXO, ARMY would flip out. Don't be that embarrassing ARMY that can't pick your ults out in a lineup. It's a bad look and spreading misinformation makes it harder for other newer ARMY to learn things and have the proper information.
There is another picture that goes around from time to time as Jungkook and that isn't him either. This picture is of Hongseok from Pentagon. Once again I called out the person posting this months ago on Threads and I told them this was not Jungkook. They proceeded to argue and when I asked for a source they gave Facebook which is not a valid source when people ask where you got something. Always provide a link. The official BTS Facebook is valid but a Facebook group or fan page is not. I told them they were wrong and provided a link I found to the photographer's X/ Twitter page where they still had this photo shoot listed proving this was Hongseok and not Jungkook. They argued that it was an edit. Why would anyone edit the pic? None of the arguments made sense and all were irrelevant once I showed proof. Blocked. Once again this is disrespectful to Jungkook and to Hongseok who deserves to be credited in his photos as himself. It's a beautiful photo shoot altogether and he's a beautiful man. He deserves to be credited properly.
Mislabeling and wrongly crediting photos to an artist is one thing. Some people sharing them have no idea because others are lying to them about who these people are so they can get attention to their accounts from having "exclusive" photos no one else has (by labeling the wrong ones as BTS). Intentionally sharing photoshopped, AI generated photos is a whole other fight in dealing with misinformation.
The issue there is that people can't tell when a picture has been faked with AI or run through apps for AI or photoshopped. Some AI photos are blurry around the outline or the shadows are all wrong. The easiest giveaway for me is when the fingers are all messed up (multiple fingers or mangled or missing) and the writing is faked or not legible (sometimes AI fakes language by trying to sort of blend letters in multiple languages together and it creates an illegible mess). Then there are the real photos that people feed into apps like Rimini (I think that is the name) and they ruin perfectly good pictures of idols by adding crappy makeup or facial "flaw" editing to them. These are the pics usually that have Taehyung with double lids on both eyes and same with Namjoon when ARMY knows Tae and Jin both have one mono lid eye and one double lid eye and both of Namjoon's eyelids are mono lids.
Besides adding makeup and giving the guys unnecessary cosmetic changes, I have seen people splicing members of two different groups together to make a sort of hybrid. This is next level weird to me. I scroll the timeline and see a photo of a BTS member with features added from someone else from another group and ask how do people have time for this nonsense? A while ago there was a fake Jimin photo going around with him in military clothes sitting in a room. The background kind of looked like a hotel though which would be odd because he was deployed. Looking at the face though, I knew something was wrong with it. Jimin is hot and this version just looked weird and over done. I used Google Lens to reverse search the photo and I found out why. It was a photo of Kai from EXO that had his face mixed with Jimin and photoshopped. The stupid things people do on the internet for attention never cease to amaze and disgust me at the same time. I think the person posting that one blocked me for correcting them because they had tons of engagement from posting the picture and when faced with taking it down they decided to leave it up because most of the comments were praising Jimin. That's fine, I shared the original to show that it was faked.
There are also videos being spread that are not BTS and are being labeled or captioned as the members. There's one that started on TikToK as a joke saying the baby Jackie Chan was in a movie with looked like Tae. Some one started spreading it with the caption cut and said it was Tae. Nevermind that Tae was a teenager when the movie came out. Because Jackie Chan did the Simvest promos with Tae they took a movie clip and lied about it being him for likes. Just don't spread things without fact checking. If you ask for a source and the poster ignores you ask other ARMYs or look it up yourself.
Have you ever used Google Lens? It can be a good app to use to get information whether you are looking for a item you saw somewhere and want to buy it, looking to find out if a photo is real or AI, or looking to see if a photo has been improperly tagged as someone else. Google Lens is available in the Google Playstore and Apple app store. Download the app and to reverse search a picture in the app you open the app and it takes you to your photo gallery. Click on the picture you want to search and Lens looks for it. It pulls up searches from across the internet where that photo was found. You may have to scroll a bit to find the proper information due to misinformation but do your research. Look for legit sites and check with knowledgeable ARMYs for confirmation or clarity. Lens doesn't always work though. Sometimes I get messages saying it's hard to identify people or a bunch of totally unrelated things. Most of the time, I get enough to work with to find out if something is real or not though. If you doubt that something is real (ex AI pics) or think it may be tagged as the wrong person but you can't confirm it, don't share it. It's that simple.
There's always a reason why I try to correct misinformation. It's not to be mean or seem like I know everything because I will be the first to admit that I don't and I'm still learning every day. How are we going to have knowledgeable new ARMYs that enjoy the fandom if they keep getting fed lies and "jokes" that no one is in on except clout chasers? Correcting things now means not having to do it later. Correcting it now means not embarrassing the fandom when the boys come back with viral posts or pics that aren't them tagged/captioned as them. We can do better.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.